Alright, as threatened, it’s time for another list of fic recs, since you guys keep churning out absolute bangers. If you missed the first list, check it out here.
As before, the rules:
- I’m limiting this list to one fic per author (but may repeat some authors from list #1.) I also link author profiles, so please check out their other fics as well!
- These are MY personal favorites. That means if you reply “you’re wrong because you missed X”, no I’m not.
Without further ado, (More of) My Favorite Shadowgast Fics:
* = fic is rated M or E
Dunamancy 101: The Practical Application of Romance Upon Two Unsuspecting Wizards by Dragonslaeyr
Professor Caleb Widogast and Dr. Essek Thelyss’ students just wanted a
break from the sheer amount of assigned readings they had. As it turned
out, both professors were single.
Events escalated from there.
It’s epistolary! It’s outsider POV! It’s a university AU! It’s literally everything you love! This fic is hilarious, heartwarming, and brilliantly rendered in the form of syllabi, chat messages between Essek and Caleb’s students, emails, and Rate My Professor reviews.
Refuge by kae_hunter
Essek watches Caleb languidly through the lashes of his usable
eye. He has unquestionably just endured the worst day of his entire
life: his title, his Den, the respect of his Queen, everything he’s
worked towards for the past half-century, crumbled to dust in an
instant. Adding injury to insult, he barely survived the two separate
ambushes set by his former colleagues long enough to deliver himself as a
warning to possibly the only people who might avert the impending
apocalypse. In the past half hour, he has been repeatedly (and very
painfully) jolted to and from the brink of death like a child’s yo-yo.
And yet…
And yet, seeing this human’s face—this foreigner, who,
not so long ago, he might have imprisoned or killed as “Empire scum”
without a second thought—the tender studiousness of Caleb Widogast’s
expression, as he gently dabs at Essek’s eyelid with a damp cloth…
Essek finds himself strangely at peace with it all.
This is an older one–to the point where it’s not canon compliant anymore–but still 110% worth a read. The author has wonderfully vivid language and a superb blend of emotion and humor (and Yussa’s appearance is a ton of fun).
Hard Mouth* by road_rhythm | @road-rhythm
There’s something in Caleb’s dreams. It wants him to know that
he’s not alone. It wants him to know that he’ll never be alone again.
Elves don’t dream, so all Essek can do is watch.
A long canon-divergence fic that assumes Caleb didn’t take Mind Blank has his eighth-level spell and Trent Ikithon played a longer game in trying to take him down. If you’re looking for the emotional equivalent of getting repeatedly knifed in the gut, this fic is for you! Warning for dark themes; please be mindful.
It used to be if you don’t like it you could leave by thought
In which the humans do a politics, the Xhorhasians learn about potatos,
and everyone decides five hundred years of living in disguise and on
the run isn’t actually a great life plan, Essek.
This fic is an absolutely delightful post-canon Shadowgast epic. It has it all: Essek and Caleb slowly inching their way into a relationship Without Talking About It, while all of Xhorhas is talking about their torrid love affair, with incredible dialogue and a beautiful look at the rest of the Mighty Nein on the side. Can’t recommend this one enough for the thoughtful worldbuilding and warm fuzzy feelings. Also, title is from “Rome” by Dessa, which is a banger.
The Upward Arc of Sun and Moon* by marsastronomica | @marsastronomica
Shadowhand Essek Thelyss of the Kryn Dynasty has been
selected to spend the year at the Soltryce Academy, teaching the basics
of an esoteric school of magic known as dunamancy. While the goal is to
build better relations between the Dwendalian Empire and the Dynasty,
it’s also the best way to prove to his mother he is committed to
furthering the reputation of their well-regarded Den.
Renowned
former adventurer Caleb Widogast has recently been appointed the
Archmage of Civil Influence. Beloved by the common folk, Caleb finds
himself frustrated with cutthroat peers and a morally lackadaisical
aristocracy. Being able to attend every dunamancy lecture, plus new
students and old friends, should keep his troubled mind away from
unfinished business.
Though Essek and Caleb met three years ago, a
misunderstanding put them at odds. The more they talk, the quicker
Essek falls into his first romance…which unknowingly leads them both
into a web of underhanded machinations.
Oh, man, I can’t say enough good things about this epic-length (seriously, long as hell, and if you’re anything like me you won’t want to stop reading) fic. It’s a gorgeous alternate universe, blending elements of canon with a university AU. The development of Caleb and Essek’s relationship is thoughtful, the dialogue is excellent, and the author even got me to enjoy things that usually aren’t to my personal taste.
Lay Your Bones by LadyOrpheus
Footsteps pad down the hall and past the stairs. Actual footsteps.
Verin can’t remember the last time he saw Essek walk on his own two
feet. He feels a twisted knot form beneath his sternum; something isn’t
right.
Thinking only of justice and restoring his family’s honor
after Essek’s betrayal, Verin Thelyss finds something he never expected,
an Essek he never expected. A mission for justice turns into a race
against time and a family finds their world upended.
A really powerful blend of kidfic and one of my personal favorite genres, ‘Essek gets arrested by the Dynasty and the M9 save him’. The use of POV is excellent and the characters are written thoughtfully and realistically.
a mirror to the sky* by renquise
Essek shows up on Caleb’s doorstep in the bitter cold of winter.
It
is still early in the day, barely three-sixteen, but the sun is already
disappearing between the city houses, leaving only blue light in the
streets. The temperature is falling with the sun and the moons are high
in the sky, white and pink shadows against the blue. Essek is dark and
indistinct in the doorway, the shape of him muffled by a heavy cloak,
and they have need of each other’s complicated company.
As with all of renquise’s fics, this is a beautiful and delicately written fic about intimacy. The dialogue is exquisite, the language and POV is impeccable.
Out of Season* by aboxthecolorofheartache | @aboxthecolourofheartache
Caleb knows what it is to be hunted. He sees it in Essek’s
careful placement of his minimal luggage, how he has not unpacked
anything more than what is needed at the moment, the modest
respectability of his nightclothes, how he sets his boots by the bedroom
door instead of on the tray in the foyer.
The Dynasty’s memory is longer than lifetimes, and
Kryn lives are already long. Ludinous Daleth keeps fat ledgers. Their
quarry will go to ground tonight with his head on Caleb’s pillow.“
Another post-canon fic about Essek on the run, and Caleb, and Essek and Caleb together. If you enjoy being punched in the gut by your own emotions, this fic is for you! This fic is so well constructed, and it manages to hurt a lot and be warm and hopeful at the same time.
the fire kept closest (burns most of all)* by mousecookie | @ariadne-mouse
“Okay, you definitely have something new,” Beau said when he stalled for too long. “Spill.”
Essek continued to chew his thumbnail. “Tour group on the lava field. There was a sudden breakout from a soft spot.”
“…And?”
He took a breath, then shrugged. “It looked like hands?”
(Aka, the spooky volcanology AU that absolutely no one asked for.)
The concept of this fic is fucking bonkers but the emotions it will cause you to have are worse! I feel especially compelled to recommend it because It’s Really That Good, No Really, I Swear. Funny and heartwrenching in equal measure.
The Climb by Chekhov | @thechekhov
It’s… the stupidest thing.
Essek grits his
teeth. It’s a trained habit - a way to redirect some of the pain without
showing any symptoms. A Shadowhand never shows his hand, and it is this
he excels at - a poker face, a well-concealed illusion of poise and
grandeur and tolerance.
But today, he is unlucky.
Because there is little that escapes the keen mind of Widogast - and here he has quite the disadvantage.
It is, quite literally, his least favored terrain.
Stairs.
—
When keeping mages in an enclosed terrarium, please keep in mind the
following: They need lots of places to hide and explore. Provide
enrichment opportunities for them to keep them from getting bored -
plenty of books, hidden treasures, and secret chambers. And if you’re
feeling bold, think about including an Anti-Magic staircase just to
challenge them. See what they do with it.
A light-hearted one to end the rec list with; while of course I love Essek and Caleb at their most tortured, have a delightfully funny one with great, snappy dialogue where they’re only at the mercy of their own pride, stupidity, and each other.
And if you’re still on the hunt for more Shadowgast fic, there is my own ouevre, but I will rec my most popular one:
only code it knows is rote survival by Chrome
Essek clung to her; his fingers gripped the front of her coat. He
looked small in a way he never had before, frightened in a way that
Caleb hadn’t fully processed he could be. It wasn’t Essek’s nervousness,
the anxiety of a brilliant man who could see danger all around him, who
could see the falling dominoes and the way the web he had woven had
entangled him. It was the fear of a small child, or indeed, a stray
cat—the fear of a creature trapped in a terrifying world it did not
understand.
Essek, brilliant Essek, Essek who believed he could find the
answers to everything, unable to understand a thing—the thought of it
stabbed at Caleb’s heart.
—
In a world where Trent makes it back to Eiselcross
before the Nein do, Essek spends a night under the effects of the
Feeblemind spell. Caleb undertakes a duty of care, and the Nein learn
how Essek feels about them beneath everything.